After the January 2025 midair collision near Washington National Airport (DCA), the NTSB cited many probable causes. But many of the key questions centered on a critical safety technology known as Automatic Dependent Surveillance–Broadcast Out, or ADS-B Out, which broadcasts an aircraft’s position, altitude, ground speed, and identification to ground stations and other aircraft. Both aircraft in the collision were equipped with ADS-B, but only one was transmitting at the time of the accident.
Sixty-seven lives were lost that night, and Congress responded with serious safety legislation. But one provision riding along with it has nothing to do with that night, and its backers are counting on lawmakers not to notice.
That provision is the Pilot and Aircraft Privacy Act, or PAPA. It was never a response to the DCA crash, but it has been tucked into the House’s ALERT Act, the bill meant to carry out the NTSB’s recommendations. PAPA would bar any government agency or airport from using ADS-B data “to identify aircraft for the purpose of obtaining revenue” without the owner’s consent. Airports could no longer use the data to bill landing fees, and state and local assessors could no longer use it to find aircraft owners who owe property and sales taxes. It addresses none of the NTSB’s findings. It is a fee and tax break for aircraft owners, dressed up as safety reform.
The Senate-passed ROTOR Act, which mandates ADS-B In to put traffic and weather directly in the cockpit, covers much of the same safety ground as ALERT without PAPA. Not one safety provision in either bill depends on it.
PAPA’s backers know a tax break for aircraft owners is a hard sell in a crash-response bill, so they have built a safety argument around it. If airports and tax collectors can use ADS-B data, they say, pilots will switch their transmitters off to avoid paying.
Here is what they leave out. ADS-B Out is not a suggestion. It is a federal rule. Except for FAA-authorized sensitive missions and air traffic control direction, any pilot flying an aircraft equipped with ADS-B Out must keep it transmitting at all times. A pilot who intentionally turns it off faces civil penalties and suspension or revocation of their pilot certificate. Those who claim pilots would gamble their certificates and their lives to save a landing fee are misrepresenting the facts for their own ends. And the data shows they are wrong.
A recent analysis of 872,373 light-aircraft takeoffs and landings at 136 airports in all 50 states, from mid-July to late September of this year, found just 31 without an ADS-B broadcast, spread across 26 different aircraft. Of the 22,401 aircraft studied, 22,375 had a perfect record. If pilots were going dark to dodge fees, the same aircraft would disappear again and again. Not one fits that pattern. The few gaps are ordinary: terrain briefly blocking a signal near the ground, an avionics fault, or a plane moved by road.
Even PAPA’s allies concede the point. When Oklahoma lawmakers considered a similar bill this year, the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association’s own representative testified that he didn’t think anyone would “go to the extreme of turning that equipment off every time they go to their home airport.” The nation’s airport associations told Congress that airport fees “typically run a small fraction of the costs” of operating an aircraft.
Pilots are trained from the moment they begin to fly that safety is everything. Safety isn’t luck. It is built on regulation, training, procedures, and technology. That is why ADS-B matters, and why it is an insult to pilots to suggest they would switch it off over a fee. Privacy deserves its own debate, but it should never be used as cover for a tax break.
PAPA’s backers are asking Congress to accept a false premise: that keeping pilots safe requires stopping governments from collecting fees and taxes that are already owed. The rules already require ADS-B to stay on, and the data shows pilots follow them. What’s left is a provision that shields aircraft owners from their bills, and it has no place in a bill written in memory of 67 people. Congress should strip PAPA out and pass a clean safety bill. We owe the victims and their families nothing less.
David Silver is an aerospace executive with more than twenty-five years of technical and policy leadership at Fortune 100 companies. He is the founder of David Silver Aerospace LLC, which advises aerospace and defense companies on supply chain, strategic planning, and government policy. A former Boeing chief engineer and director, and former Vice President of Civil Aviation at the Aerospace Industries Association, he is also a retired Lieutenant Colonel in the U.S. Army National Guard and a Distinguished Graduate of the Command and General Staff College.

The American people sent a clear message this election: Congress must put affordability front and center, and that…

Over the past several decades, extraordinary breakthroughs in cancer research and treatment have transformed patient outcomes, offering renewed…

All year, moderate women told me they weren’t sure their ballots would be counted fairly. On November 3,…
On the record or off. Lawmakers, staffers, lobbyists, journalists — if it belongs on Capitol Hill, we want to hear it.
Thanks for reaching out. We review every pitch and will follow up if we want to pursue the story.